Thursday, May 28, 2009

Gwinnett County Commission Backs Down

Jim Galloway reports that Gwinnett County Commission Chairman Charles Bannister is going to table the proposed 25% increase in property taxes. Bannister said 'We have heard the message sent to us by the citizens.' However, if the June 1st Tax Protest has not been tabled he may not have heard anything yet.

Fun With Deficits

The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities has some tables showing the current and projected budget gaps for states that face budget deficits.

Interesting to me is the 9 states with no income tax have a combined projected budget gap of $15.2 billion. The three states (New Jersey, New York and California) with the highest tax burden as determined by the Tax Foundation also have the three highest projected budget gaps for 2010. California's projected deficit of $33.9 billion is more than double the combined gap of the states with no income tax. New Jersey and New York face more modest deficits of $7.0 billion and $17.9 billion, respectively, though that still places them 2nd and 3rd in size.

At what point do states stop to think if high taxes are really the solution to overspending?

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

If You Don't Like Rich People Just Tax Them Out Of Your State II

Maryland has lost one-third of its millionaires from a year ago. In 2008, Marland had 3,000 million dollar income tax returns filed by the end of April. In 2009, that number dropped to 2,000 according to a WSJ editorial. For sure, many of these taxpayers are still Maryland residents whose incomes dropped below one million dollars because of the recession, but it is bad policy to depend more and more on the wealthy to fund bloated governments.

It's interesting to note that three of the most heavily taxed states (California, New York and New Jersey) are experiencing huge budget deficits while the 9 states with NO income taxes are largely faring well.

State governments need to consider three things when they adopt a 'soak the rich' tax policy:
  1. Do you want to create an environment where the wealthy are inclined to move out?
  2. Do you want to create an environment where wealthy out-of-state residents are discouraged from moving in?
  3. Do you want to create an additional incentive for residents to legally shelter or deferr income recognition?

Each of these three scenarios would also adversely impact a local government's ability to collect tax revenues related to property and sales taxes.

If You Don't Like Rich People, Just Tax Them Out Of Your State

There may be a battle forming in the New Jersey GOP primary for Governor. According to this WSJ editorial, Steve Lonegan is proposing a flat tax in lieu of the existing graduated income tax. New Jersey has one of the highest tax burdens in the country. Lonegan's plan would at the least make it one of the least burdened states in the northeast which is important to note considering the ease with which residents can move. The editorial says that New Jersey has suffered the nations 4th highest rate of out-migration of all the states. Lonegan doesn't want residents who are expected to fund many of the tax revenues to move out of the state's tax reach which is the main idea behind a low (2.98%) rate on each taxpayer's first dollar of income.

It will be interesting to watch how the current frontrunner Chris Christie will continue to attack the flat tax as a tax on the poor without being perceived as Republican engaged in the typical Democratic strategy of class warfare.

I Thought You Were Republicans...Whatever Those Are.

The AJC reports on another county that is proposing a tax rate increase. This time it's Gwinnett County resident's turn to complain about a possible 25% increase to property tax rates. The county is claiming it has lost revenues of $839 million dollars over more than a decade by not raisng the millage rate. The county doesn't mention that new construction and increased assessments have occured during the same time.

The best quote comes from Peter Henrickson of Duluth, 'I thought you were Republicans.' The fact that any members of the commission are Republicans means they will spend other people's money like a drunken sailor while they hold office and then bemoan any spending or tax increases when they are voted out.

Oddly, neither this article nor last week's article mentions anything about a county financed baseball stadium. You can read how the stadium (and a 25% increase in property taxes) will pay for itself from day one here.

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Tax Increases to Lobby for More Tax Increases?

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reports that taxes are paying $25 million in lobbyists salaries. Almost one-fourth of the more than 1600 peopled registered to lobby during the 2009 session represented either state funded agencies or local governments. As Rep. John Lunsford of McDonough says, 'The only person without a damn lobbyist is the taxpayer.'

I have no problem with lobbying in general. I do not believe that spending money to petition the government is tantamount to 'buying' politicians. There is something, however, that rankles me about taxpayers' money being used to lobby positions that are often against the taxpayers best interest. As Jared Thomas of the Georgia chapter of Americans for Prosperity says, 'Essentially what you've got is tax dollars being used to send people to the state Capital to lobby lawmakers to raise their taxes again.'

There were many valid reasons to oppose Glenn Richardson's plan to eliminate local property taxes in the state of Georgia. Local governments using taxpayer money to ensure property taxes were not cut shouldn't be one of them.

Friday, May 22, 2009

More Property Tax News

Pickens County Chief Tax Appraiser Roy Dobbs says the property tax value freeze is confusing and will be a long term disappointment to property owners. According to Dobbs there are a few 'nothing is set' and 'wait and see' items creating confusion for tax offices across the state. I think this can be interpreted as we know how much money we have to collected, now we have to do the 5th grade math to calculate our millage rate. The lawsuit filed against DeKalb county may give other counties an indication of how much leeway they have.

He freely admits that "Property taxes are not frozen....it's only the assessments." It probably is reasonable to believe that most Georgians will not see a decrease in their property taxes and many in fact may pay more than prior years.

The most frustrating thing about the tax appraiser's comments is this: 'Tax bills are dictated by budgets.' This isn't really news, but it still is frustrating. Every business and household starts with projected available resources and budgets how to spend, but local governements create a spending plan and then work backwords to shake the revenue out of the taxpayers' pockets.

Is it any wonder that surveys typically reveal property taxes are the most hated of all other types of taxes?